Barnes & Noble, the Last Big Bookseller Standing: But for How Long?

The online business journal Knowledge@Wharton (@knowledgwharton) scrutinizes the possible future of Barnes & Noble (@BNBuzz), which operates 689 bookstores in 50 states and 674 college bookstores.

The chain is caught between the need to bolster its in-store experience, and the drive to keep up in an ever-growing tablet market as readers increasingly turn away from printed books.

Barbara Kahn, director of the Jay H. Baker Retailing Center (@whartonretail) says Barnes & Noble's merchandising isn't giving consumers much of a reason to visit stores. "The best retailers are experiential," she says. "Online retailers can provide big assortments and better prices. If a retailer focuses on price and category, online [retailers] will always win. Barnes & Noble has to ... do what online can't do -- social interaction, physical presence, and experience."

...One of Barnes & Noble's core assets may be the people on its sales floor. "The more the retailer can provide service with a face on it and provide amenities, the better chance it has of surviving," says Wharton management professor Daniel Raff. "You can create a destination for merchandise and prices, but service and a response to your desires will get you ambiance.... If Barnes & Noble is just about buying books, customers can get that online. But what if it can also provide customers with insights from, and conversations with, people who understand the experience? Barnes & Noble has to figure out what makes it a good retailer and play to its strengths."

Read this in full.

In an interview in The Wall Street Journal ("B&N Aims To Whittle Its Stores For Years"), CEO Mitchell Klipper says that, while B&N still sees growth left in the physical book business, it plans to close about 1/3 of its stores over the next decade, bringing the total remaining shops to around 450 to 500. Klipper says less than 20 of B&N's total retail stores are money losers. Overall, the retail stores still make solid profits; enough to offset losses from the Nook business.

Be sure to download our white paper, “Tech, Trends, & Retail Success: See the Future and Act Now,” in which we explain how 7 Cs – Casual, Current, Convenient, Communal, Collective, Convivial, Confident – can help retailers create an extreme in-store experience for customers.

Contact Somersault (@smrsault) to help you strategically publish and market pbooks, ebooks, and audiobooks.

Learn about SomersaultSocial (@SomersaultHelp) our Web-based author online marketing education modules.

Add our Facebook page (http://facebook.com/SomersaultGroup) & Twitter stream (http://twitter.com/smrsault) to your Flipboard account on your iPad, iPhone, or Android. 

Get our blogposts delivered into your email inbox.

And be sure to bookmark and use daily the SomersaultNOW online dashboard; especially the Book Discovery Sites tab.

1 response
Fascinating evaluation, although I think probably too pessimistic. It's too early to pound the nails in Barnes & Noble's coffin. It may come to that, but they still have some cards they can play, and there are still market segments that don't buy online and don't use ereaders.
I agree, though, that big-box stores like B&N and Best Buy are in an awkward position. They de-emphasized the role of the sales staff and emphasized self-service and selection and price. But now Amazon is beating them at their own game. If you want informed input from the staff, you don't go to a big-box store, you go to your local independent. Now B&N has to change that perspective, but it won't be easy.
The article said that Jeff Bezos of Amazon cares more about revenue than profit margin. I think what publishers discovered during the e-book pricing wars was that Amazon cares more about market share than it cares about either revenue or profit.

David Lambert Editorial Director, Somersault www.somersaultgroup.com 616-446-8042